WEKO3
アイテム
アリストテレスのディアレクティケーの理論の発展
https://doi.org/10.15027/39688
https://doi.org/10.15027/39688fbe99f70-ea57-45bc-8c65-0e18065a8216
| 名前 / ファイル | ライセンス | アクション |
|---|---|---|
Ann-ResProjCent-CompStudLogic_13_7.pdf (272.6 KB)
|
| Item type | デフォルトアイテムタイプ_（フル）(1) | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 公開日 | 2023-03-18 | |||||||||
| タイトル | ||||||||||
| タイトル | アリストテレスのディアレクティケーの理論の発展 | |||||||||
| 言語 | ja | |||||||||
| タイトル | ||||||||||
| タイトル | Development of Aristotle’s Dialectic | |||||||||
| 言語 | en | |||||||||
| 作成者 |
高橋, 祥吾
× 高橋, 祥吾
|
|||||||||
| アクセス権 | ||||||||||
| アクセス権 | open access | |||||||||
| アクセス権URI | http://purl.org/coar/access_right/c_abf2 | |||||||||
| 主題 | ||||||||||
| 主題Scheme | NDC | |||||||||
| 主題 | 130 | |||||||||
| 内容記述 | ||||||||||
| 内容記述 | In his Topics Aristotle sets up the theory of dialectic, which he seems not to use in his other works. This must be accounted for. Irwin assumes that there is a distinction in dialectic: pure and strong. But in my opinion Aristotle’s theory of dialectic has undergone development from an inchoate one into a revised one: the former is found in Topics while the latter in Rhetoric. The theory of dialectic in Topics is not full-blown. To explain. Aristotle there asserts that there are four predicables: definition, property, genus, accident and that a set of the predicables, which are mutually exclusive, is exhaustive. However, per se accident does not fall under any of these. Traditionally per se accident has been interpreted to be a sort of property. As Burnes pointed out, however, per se accident does not have to fit the definition of a property. This implies that in Topics the four predicables are not well defined. Alexander points out that there is an inseparable accident, which is an attribute that belongs to something but is not separate from it. It is noteworthy that the inseparable accident, fitting the first definition of accident given in Topics, does not fit its second definition given there. Aristotle holds that the first definition is equivalent to the second. If this is the case, it will follow that the concept of an inseparable accident contradicts his own idea. Many scholars do not take this fact into account. But, in my opinion, this fact shows that Aristotle has abandoned the theory of dialectic in Topics and introduces a pair of per se and accident in Posterior Analytics instead. In addition, the dialectic Aristotle discusses in Rhetoric is a revised dialectic. For the explanation of topos has greatly changed. Aristotle distinguishes ‘common’ topos from ‘peculiar’ topos. According to him, the common topos applies for different objects, while the peculiar topos applies for a specific object. This peculiar topos is mentioned in Rhetoric I. 7. Peculiar topos in Rhetoric I. 7 is common to topos in Topics III. On the other hand, the common topos in Rhetoric II 27 is common to the ‘most opportune topos,’ which is referred to in Topics III and VII. The distinction of ‘common’ and ‘peculiar’ is also used in the theory of demonstration. We may say that the theory of demonstration has an influence on the revised dialectic. | |||||||||
| 言語 | en | |||||||||
| 内容記述 | ||||||||||
| 内容記述タイプ | Other | |||||||||
| 内容記述 | 広島大学比較論理学プロジェクト研究センター研究成果報告書（2015年度） | |||||||||
| 内容記述 | ||||||||||
| 内容記述タイプ | Other | |||||||||
| 内容記述 | 本発表は，平成27年度文部科学省科学研究費補助金（研究活動スタート支援）「アリストテレスの問答法の理論とその発展的解釈の研究」(研究課題番号：15H06815) の研究成果の一部である． | |||||||||
| 出版者 | ||||||||||
| 出版者 | 広島大学比較論理学プロジェクト研究センター | |||||||||
| 言語 | ||||||||||
| 言語 | jpn | |||||||||
| 資源タイプ | ||||||||||
| 資源タイプ識別子 | http://purl.org/coar/resource_type/c_6501 | |||||||||
| 資源タイプ | departmental bulletin paper | |||||||||
| 出版タイプ | ||||||||||
| 出版タイプ | VoR | |||||||||
| 出版タイプResource | http://purl.org/coar/version/c_970fb48d4fbd8a85 | |||||||||
| ID登録 | ||||||||||
| ID登録 | 10.15027/39688 | |||||||||
| ID登録タイプ | JaLC | |||||||||
| 収録物識別子 | ||||||||||
| 収録物識別子タイプ | ISSN | |||||||||
| 収録物識別子 | 1880-6376 | |||||||||
| 収録物識別子 | ||||||||||
| 収録物識別子タイプ | NCID | |||||||||
| 収録物識別子 | AA12025285 | |||||||||
| 開始ページ | ||||||||||
| 開始ページ | 7 | |||||||||
| 書誌情報 |
比較論理学研究 The Annals of the Research Project Center for the Comparative Study of Logic 号 13, p. 7-17, 発行日 2016-03-25 |
|||||||||
| 旧ID | 39688 | |||||||||
